Babe Ruth's granddaughter visits new collectible store

Published on Wednesday, 20 December 2017 14:40
Written by Erica Schmitt

Staff Writer

NEWINGTON - John Kelleher has the dream job of many, peddling away treasures he’s spent a lifetime collecting.

The East Hartford resident just opened M&J Video Games & Sports Collectibles at 3277 Berlin Turnpike. It’s his family’s second store in Connecticut, with the first location on Queen Street in Southington. Kelleher had a store in Wallingford, but closed up shop after a brief stint and moved to a plaza on Route 15 in Newington late in the fall.

“Wallingford customers would call me and say, ‘There’s no place to park, I’ll come back another time,’” he says. “I thought, ‘What better place than the yurnpike? Thousands of cars come by here every day and we have more than enough parking.”

They needed it last weekend, when two famous guests stopped by for the store’s grand opening.

A pro-wrestling legend began the festivities Friday evening. Saturday, staff unveiled their new signage at a ribbon-cutting ceremony. Sunday, Babe Ruth’s granddaughter, Linda Ruth Tosetti, joined the party.

It’s Kelleher’s personal experience in the sports entertainment industry that brings big names into his two stores. He worked as Rocky the Rock Cat for 11 years for the former New Britain Rock Cats baseball franchise.

That’s also how he came across some of the rarer items on his shelves, like a three-foot-tall Babe Ruth bobble-head doll.

“Only 100 of these were made,” Kelleher says proudly, placing a Santa Claus hat on the figure’s head.

Each piece comes along with a story. Maybe where it originated, how it was discovered or who he bought it from.

The Newington store features hundreds of sports memorabilia, much of it signed by major league baseball players, pro wrestlers, hockey legends, football greats and basketball champs.

Video game systems, games and other equipment take an equal share in the collection. But not the latest and greatest think more vintage.

“We have two warehouses filled with stuff,” Kelleher says. “What’s unique about my store is that it doesn’t just cover one type of collectible. Our motto is, if you want it, we’ll get it for you.”

This kind of passion for treasure hunting is not learned in school. Kelleher grew up on the flea market and swap meet circuit, hanging on the coattails of a precious metals dealer.

“I was maybe 8 or 9 years old and my dad would take me to all these shows,” he recalled. “He sold gold and silver. When he’d buy big lots out there would be tons of extra junk, so he’d have me sell it for him. By the late ’80s, I was 18 and I was making three hundred bucks every weekend.”

Nowadays, fellow gaming aficionados and sports fans come into the store and find a friend in Kelleher. They chat up the afternoon and on their way out, are astounded to discover the missing piece in their collection.

For him, it’s these moments that make the daily organizing and hunting worth every hassle and haggle.

“When you help them out you feel good,” Kelleher says. “That’s what we’re here for.”

Right now M&J is in the middle of its Twelve Days of Christmas Sale. Each day up until Dec. 25 a different featured item will be on sale. The store’s regular hours are Monday through Saturday, from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. and Sunday, from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m.11-7.

Erica Schmitt can be reached at 860-801-5097, or

Posted in Newington Town Crier, Newington News on Wednesday, 20 December 2017 14:40. Updated: Wednesday, 20 December 2017 14:42.